Collar or harness – which is actually better? Both options have advantages – but also disadvantages that should be considered. Here you'll find all the important information to help you decide.
Why the right choice is so important
The right accessories for your dog can affect your dog's health, safety, and everyday suitability . Inappropriate collars or harnesses can cause pain or even health problems.
The collar – classic, practical, often underestimated
Advantages of the collar
- More control: Because the collar sits at the front of the neck, the leash is closer to the head. This often gives you more control over your dog's handling than with a harness, where the leash attaches further back.
- Quick to put on and take off: Especially practical for short walks or a quick walk.
- More freedom of movement: Many dogs find a collar less disruptive.
Disadvantages of the collar
- Pressure on the larynx and cervical vertebrae: Particularly dangerous in dogs that pull hard and run into the leash.
- Health risks: May cause long-term damage.
- Not suitable for all dogs: Especially problematic for small breeds or short-nosed dogs.
When a collar makes sense
- For calm, leash-trained dogs .
- When maximum control is required in certain situations (e.g. B. city traffic, dog encounters).
- In combination with a harness for double protection (e.g. B. in anxious dogs).
Types of collars – and why the pin buckle is often safer
Not all collars are created equal. Snap fasteners, pin buckles, stoppers, leather, nylon, rope… there's a wide selection of fasteners and materials. Especially with larger dogs , you should place great emphasis on stability.
Pin buckle collars (like those on a belt) are considered more secure. They can't break due to material fatigue or accidental pressure—unlike simple snap fasteners, which can fail more quickly under strong tension or cold. Pin buckles also reduce the risk of the length becoming unadjusted over time, resulting in the collar becoming too loose.
While snap fasteners are practical for everyday use, there's a greater risk of them accidentally opening with very active, anxious, or strong dogs. High-quality snap fasteners made of metal or safety plastic offer slightly more protection but should be checked regularly for wear.
Animal welfare-relevant collars
Although it should go without saying, we don't want to leave unmentioned that there are collars that are absolutely taboo. In Germany, the use of so-called animal welfare-contrary devices is prohibited by law. These include:
- Prong collars
- Choke collars without stop
- Electric or spray collars
The harness – comfortable, safe and versatile
Advantages of the dishes
- Gentle on the throat: No pressure on the trachea or larynx.
- Secure hold: Especially for anxious dogs or animals that pull hard.
- Anatomically often more sensible: Recommended for breeds such as pugs, which should not wear a collar due to their body shape and breathing problems.
Disadvantages of the dishes
- Less direct control: The leash is attached further back, giving you less influence over the dog's head movement.
- Promotes pulling behavior: For dogs that already pull hard, the harness can make pulling even more pleasant.
- The fit is crucial: A poorly fitting harness can cause chafing or restrict movement.
Not all dishes are the same – an overview of the differences
Everyday tableware
- For normal walks.
- Comfortable, light and flexible.
Safety harness
- With additional belly strap to prevent wriggling out.
- Ideal for anxious or insecure dogs .
- Can be combined with a collar – so-called double security .
Harness (e.g. B. Canicross, Bikejoring)
- Especially for sporting activities.
- Anatomically cut so that the dog can pull powerfully without being harmed.
- Only suitable for the purpose of dog sledding – not for everyday use!
How should a collar fit?
- Two fingers distance between neck and band.
- Not on the larynx , but slightly above it.
- Adjust width : Narrow enough not to be constricting, wide enough not to be tight.
- Material and closure should be robust, secure and comfortable.
How should a harness fit?
- Y-shaped design for free shoulder movement.
- The belt must not cut into the armpits .
- There should be enough space between each strap and your body for two fingers .
- Adjustability is crucial – every harness must be adjusted to the dog’s body.
Conclusion: Collar or harness – which suits your dog?
The good thing is: There is no “right” or “wrong” , only what suits your dog and your everyday life .
If your dog is calm and behaves well on a leash, a collar can work wonderfully. For active, young, sensitive, or anxious dogs, a harness is often a better choice—especially during training or sports.
👉 The important thing is: It has to fit properly!
A poorly fitting collar or harness can do more harm than good.
Extra tip: Use the combination
By the way, you don't always have to choose. Many dog owners use both :
- Collar for short walks or as “everyday identification” with tag.
- Harness for walks, training and excursions.
This allows you to combine safety, comfort and control flexibly – depending on the situation.
Are you unsure what suits your dog better?
Talk to your vet, trainer, or get advice from a specialist retailer—and try out different models at your leisure. Your dog will thank you! 🐾
You can also make your four-legged friend happy with our natural supplementary foods and tasty training snacks !
